The original Oldboy is a slow, agonizing burn. The remake feels like it’s on fast-forward. We get only a few minutes of Joe’s imprisonment before he’s out. The emotional weight of 20 years of isolation is glossed over. Spike Lee tries to cram 120 minutes of story into 104 minutes, and the result feels breathless and shallow.
Then, just as suddenly as he disappeared, he is released. Given a cell phone, money, and a suit, Joe must find out who imprisoned him—and why—in 46 hours. His only ally is a young social worker, Marie (Elizabeth Olsen). The trail leads to a mysterious, wealthy man named Adrian (Sharlto Copley), who holds the key to a secret more horrifying than revenge. 1. Josh Brolin’s Physicality Brolin is no Choi Min-sik, but he brings a different energy. Where the original Oldboy (Dae-su) was fragile and weeping, Brolin’s Joe is a bull in a china shop. He is physically imposing, angry, and feral. His transformation from a bloated prisoner to a lean, scarred weapon is genuinely impressive. When he rips his way out of a glass box or fights off a dozen men, you believe he could actually do it. Phim Oldboy 2013
Oldboy (2013): Why Spike Lee’s Remake Isn’t the Disaster You Remember (But Still Has Big Problems) The original Oldboy is a slow, agonizing burn