While the action is smooth, the character models suffer from “budget-era DC direct-to-video” stiffness. Faces are flat, backgrounds are minimal, and the digital ink often looks smudged. Compared to later DC films ( Batman: Under the Red Hood , Justice League: Doom ), this one shows its age. Also, the asteroid’s CGI stands out awkwardly against the 2D characters.
Beneath the superhero slugfests lies a clever commentary on fear-mongering, media manipulation, and public panic. Lex Luthor as a populist president (voiced with oily charm by Clancy Brown) feels more relevant now than in 2009. His use of a “metahuman threat” to consolidate power and turn allies into enemies mirrors real-world demagoguery. The subplot of Major Force murdering a hero to frame Superman adds genuine tension. Superman Batman Public Enemies -2009- -tmdbid-2...
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies is the cinematic equivalent of a “greatest hits” album—exciting in bursts, but lacking the depth of a full studio record. It succeeds as a fast-paced action romp and a showcase for the unmatched Conroy-Daly chemistry. It fails as a coherent adaptation of a beloved comic, sacrificing character moments for fight scenes. While the action is smooth, the character models
Lex Luthor is the mastermind, but he’s sidelined until the finale. In his place, we get a parade of physical threats: Metallo (disposable), Amazo (too powerful, defeated too easily), and a secret Doomsday cameo that feels like fan service. The best villains are those who challenge the heroes ideologically, but Public Enemies favors punching over debating. Also, the asteroid’s CGI stands out awkwardly against
True to its comic book roots, Public Enemies rarely pauses for breath. The film throws the duo into a gauntlet of fights: vs. Metallo, vs. Captain Atom, vs. a swarm of B- and C-list villains (Lady Shiva, Nightshade, Mongul). The animation by Sam Liu and the team at Warner Bros. Animation is fluid and dynamic, capturing Ed McGuinness’s exaggerated, bulky character designs. The final battle against a giant, kryptonite-infused Amazo is a visual highlight.
Its sequel-adjacent film, Superman/Batman: Apocalypse (2010), which continues the story with a stronger focus on Supergirl.